Crafty Afternoon Book

Yarn, paper and paint for a creative afternoon

Student or craft acrylics? Paint for beginners, per the ACMI seal

Courtney Clark Avatar

·

3 min read

Walk down the paint aisle and you will see three kinds of acrylics on the shelf: small bottles labeled craft paint, mid-priced tubes called student grade, and pricier tubes marked artist quality. They look similar, but they behave differently on the brush. Knowing the difference keeps you from overspending on a project that does not need it, or from fighting a paint that will not cover.

What makes the three types different

Acrylic paint is pigment suspended in a plastic binder. Two things set the types apart: how much pigment there is, and how thick the paint is.

  • Craft acrylics come in squeeze bottles, are thin and creamy, and usually contain less pigment and more filler. They are great for painting wood, signs, and cardboard, and for projects with children.
  • Student acrylics have more pigment and a thicker body. They mix well and are the best choice for a beginner who wants to learn color mixing and painting on canvas.
  • Artist acrylics have the highest pigment load, the richest color, and the best lightfastness. They cost more per tube, and they are worth it when you want a painting to last decades.

Thickness matters, too. A thicker paint holds the mark of a brush and covers a dark surface in one coat. A thinner paint flows easily and levels out, but you may need two or three coats.

A quick comparison

Type Pigment level Price per ounce Best for
Craft acrylic, squeeze bottle (store label) Low to medium Often under $1 Wood, cardboard, rocks, kids’ projects
Student-grade acrylic, tube or tub Medium Often $1 to $3 Canvas, color-mixing practice, sketches
Artist-grade acrylic, tube High Often $3 to $10 or more Finished paintings, layered glazes, archival work

Prices change by store and by color, so use these ranges only as a rough guide. Price per ounce is the useful number, because a big bottle of cheap paint can cost less per ounce than a tiny tube, yet hold far less pigment.

Look for the ACMI seal

On the back of a paint bottle, you may see a seal that reads AP, short for Approved Product, from the Art and Creative Materials Institute. It means the product was reviewed by a toxicologist and is labeled according to federal standards. You can read more at the ACMI website.

The seal is a helpful starting point, but it is not a guarantee that a paint is safe to eat or that it suits every age. Read the warnings, keep the room ventilated, and wash your hands after painting. For young children, adults should choose and supervise the materials.

Which one should you buy?

  1. Canvas or canvas board: student acrylics. They blend smoothly, and mistakes are easy to paint over.
  2. Wood, cardboard, or craft projects: craft acrylics. They are cheap, they cover well, and the color range is wide.
  3. A gift or something you want to keep: artist acrylics in a few key colors. A small set of five tubes goes a long way.

A starter palette does not need many colors. Buy a warm and a cool version of red, yellow, and blue, plus white, and mix everything else. Mixing teaches you more about color than any shelf of pre-mixed bottles.

Finally, keep the lids tight and the tubes clean. Acrylic dries fast, and a dried cap is the quickest way to waste paint you have already paid for. A damp paper towel over a palette keeps the colors workable for the length of an afternoon.


Courtney Clark Avatar

You might also like